BMW M3 Forum.com (E30 M3 | E36 M3 | E46 M3 | E92 M3 | F80/X)

BMW M3 Forum.com (E30 M3 | E36 M3 | E46 M3 | E92 M3 | F80/X) (http://www.m3forum.net/m3forum/index.php)
-   E36 M3 (1992-1999) (http://www.m3forum.net/m3forum/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   To mod or not to mod, that is the question.. (http://www.m3forum.net/m3forum/showthread.php?t=579155)

carpetbagger Mon, May-01-2017 01:56:43 AM

To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
Greetings, everyone. Last June, I picked up this 1998 titanium silver coupe and I am trying to figure out what do with it. I was really looking for white or estoril, but It eventually became a bit of an emotional purchase. Admittedly, I have had some buyer's remorse (wanting a car for 22 years builds some unrealistic expectations), and while I am warming to the car, I still wonder if I should do the various things I had planned. Specifically, I wanted to turn this into a full Dinan car (tune, intake, throttle body, exhaust, suspension, etc.). The car is mostly stock, with the only changes being (1) Dinan tune, (2) upgrade to the 18-button obc, and (3) upgrade to the business cd.

As I approach my first anniversary of ownership, I am faced with the choice of do I do the mods. The OEM nature of the car makes me wonder if I would be better off leaving it as is from a resale standpoint, which then becomes a bigger issue if I try and sell it. If I were to sell it and try to find a white or blue one that is more aligned with my original idea, I think I would look for something I could just enjoy as a driver and mod it however I want, resale be damned. Having never driven a car with all of the Dinan goodies, I can't anticipate the real world difference (and yes, I have watched the YouTube exhaust videos).

So I am reaching out to see what you all think, as you all have more experience with your mods amd the ROI you got from them, as well as how you have felt after years of owning your car. What do you say - keep stock? Mod? Sell and start over? Sell and just buy the 987, 981, or 997.1 that is next on my list?

TheJDub-E36 Mon, May-01-2017 02:08:08 AM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
My car (98 sedan) is full bolt on's + cams and I absolutely love it, but I also miss it being stock with less issues:/

If I were to acquire another M3 I would keep it much closer to sock.

fiveightandten Mon, May-01-2017 03:26:19 AM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
The Dinan tune, intake, BBTB, and exhaust make the car louder. The suspension lowers it slightly (more in the rear than the front, usually). It's not going to make it into a new car or anything. Yank the baffles out of your air box and you'll get an idea of how it will sound. The handling isn't that different on Dinan suspension (Ebiachs and Konis). Snappier response to directional changes and a little less body roll.

I don't really know anything about you, but to me it sounds like you bought the wrong car. You've had it a year and you're talking about modding it in the same post as talking about selling it to buy a different color, or selling it to buy a P-car.

pbonsalb Mon, May-01-2017 03:44:54 AM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
Buy one of the Porsches on your list. I have had a 99M3 for 12 years and done pretty much all the suspension and mechanical mods. My next car will be a 997TT. The E36 is getting old. Unless you want an old car, I'd buy something newer. E46M3 (Great cars and 90 more hp than the E36)? E90M3 (I have had one for 7 years and like it)? Porsche Cayman or 911?

westopher Mon, May-01-2017 04:57:26 AM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
The fact you mentioned ROI, makes me think you should stay away from the mods. You aren't gonna get your money back from them. It doesn't sound like you love the car. I agree with pbonsalb, even though him and I feel drastically different about e36s. Move on to the next one.

pbonsalb Mon, May-01-2017 11:15:35 AM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
I never think about ROI with cars. I buy them to enjoy. And when I mod them I don't expect to get anything back. I buy used and carefully and do my own work to save money. I also drive my cars, rain and snow included. I have fun cars because I bought them to drive not to park while I drive a Honda or Jeep or whatever.

tripitz Mon, May-01-2017 12:23:52 PM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
You cannot really compare the E36 to a car like the 997. The 997 is just an amazing car and significantly newer and more modern. To me, the M3 does not come alive until you breath some additional life into it. All it really needs is suspension work. If you want to build a real appreciation for this car, you need to take it to the track. As a "car" for street use, time and technologies have moved on. At the track, this car starts to really shine. When you drive it to and from the track and then enjoy it day to day, that's when you may really start to love the car.

I owned 3 M3s and a 997; they're all amazing in their own way.

egebhardt Mon, May-01-2017 12:47:52 PM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by carpetbagger (Post 1067643473)
So I am reaching out to see what you all think, as you all have more experience with your mods amd the ROI you got from them,

You get back about 10 cents for every dollar you spend on mods but I think you are talking about 'amount of pleasure' from mods.

JitteryJoe Mon, May-01-2017 01:12:55 PM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
Sell it to someone who will really appreciate it. It looks like a solid car (based on the BaT ad). Nothing wrong with wanting to move on to another car.

carpetbagger Mon, May-01-2017 05:46:09 PM

Re: To mod or not to mod, that is the question..
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by egebhardt (Post 1067643628)
You get back about 10 cents for every dollar you spend on mods but I think you are talking about 'amount of pleasure' from mods.

That is correct. I know I can't spend x on mods and add it to the resale price. So that specific sentence was about enjoyment ROI. I would assume most potential buyers down the road wouldn't be averse to a car with the Dinan stuff should I do it.

As for the other comments, thank you all. In a perfect world, I would keep the m3 and still get the 997. As I mentioned in the initial post, I am warming to true car. I went down to the Mitty at Road Atlanta in April and had fun on the country road tour I took through Classic Motorsports and the laps on the track I did both Friday and Saturday.

Maybe I will just give it a bit more time. It will be going down to the Barber Historics later this month and perhaps the Trissl Porsche event this weekend. N


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:17:12 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 1999-2017 M3Forum.com